When you take your seat at the Winter Garden Theatre, the staff are dancing in the aisles. Throughout the play, pink confetti rain down on the actors. A giant, inflatable pink heart sits center stage. There are furry costumes and a lot of butt-forward dancing. Tom Hiddleston opens his shirt to reveal his six-pack.
I have vacillated on whether Much Ado About Nothing is a lighter comedy (like The Merry Wives of Windsor) or a darker one (like Measure for Measure)—there are flickers violence here, but the central villain, Don John (Tim Steed), is a relative lightweight. I would suspect director Jamie Lloyd has not. With a confidence I came to resent, this production insists that you are having a really good time. The energy is at a constant ten. Somewhere along the way, the story has been sacrificed to spectacle.
Consider the scenic design by Soutra Gilmour. The aforementioned heart constitutes the bulk of it, and the action appears to unfold in some kind of club-tinged void. Much Ado is driven by overhearing—the word nothing was homophonous with noting in Shakespeare’s England—and it is difficult to imbue the act of overhearing with dramatic tension when you have so sense of space. Moreover, the lack of setting encourages the actors to resort to standing-in-a-line blocking, a rather dull scaffolding for the play’s verbal fireworks.
For full disclosure, the audience at the performance I attended was having a blast. When Hiddleston brought out a standee of his Marvel character Loki, they roared.
Much Ado About Nothing runs through January 10th at the Winter Garden Theatre. 1634 Broadway New York, NY. 2 hours 20 minutes. One intermission. Photograph by Andy Henderson.